
When schools evaluate students with dyslexia, the data they collect can play a critical role in determining eligibility for special education services. But what happens when those assessments fail to capture a child’s true learning challenges?
Drawing on her professional background in data strategy and the experiences of other families, a mother of two children with dyslexia explores five common gaps in school evaluation practices. From incomplete assessments and misleading composite scores to overlooked independent evaluations, she shares practical insights to help parents ask informed questions, advocate for their children, and ensure that educational decisions reflect their children’s unique learning needs.
I have decades of professional experience in data strategy. In my work serving Fortune 500 companies, I use data to understand the market landscape and make decisions about how businesses should respond.
Sitting at school, in my dyslexic son’s REED (Review of Existing Evaluation Data) meeting, I feel particularly capable of managing the numbers with the MET (Multidisciplinary Evaluation Team). In fact, my familiarity with data strategy makes the meeting feel relatively devoid of emotion. I can manage numbers much better than the deep concern I feel for my struggling (and brilliant!) 4th grade son.
In the meeting, I uncovered several gaps in the school’s analysis. So, I talked to other parents to see if they experienced similar data manipulation regarding their child’s SLD (Specific Learning Disability) evaluation. There’s a pattern. Schools are consistently failing to identify the needs of dyslexic students. Here are the five most common gaps experienced by parents of dyslexic kids.
Five Common Data Gaps in School Analysis
1. Incomplete Assessments
Assessment selection should examine a child’s broad functioning, while properly interrogating areas of concern. Incomplete assessments result in a data narrative that shows average (or above) performance, without exposing weaknesses in areas like working memory, phonemic awareness, reading fluency, and reading comprehension. High performing dyslexic students with spiky cognitive profiles can have profound weaknesses that are not apparent in a shallow evaluation.
Experience Shared from the Community:
The school’s education specialist performing the evaluation excluded all timed-based measures needed to understand a reading fluency deficiency, focusing the evaluation on our child’s known strengths. Then, the strength-biased evaluation data was used to withdraw IEP eligibility.
2. Accommodations that Mask a Weakness
Many public schools provide universal accommodations. These accommodations can include things like audio, small group, speech-to-text, and extra time. Testing accommodations can produce data that hide a critical deficit. Parents should understand what accommodations a child is given and how those accommodations impact evaluation results.
Experience Shared from the Community:
Our child took a standardized test and received a score well above average. The result was presented to us as a comprehensive reading score. With audio accommodations used by the child, the high score measures listening comprehension and not decoding. Our district used the high score as proof that our child does not require decoding support.
3. Score Inflation
Score Inflation occurs when data are softened, merged, or eliminated, presenting a biased narrative. For example, a child with extremely high comprehension skills and low decoding skills (typical of the dyslexic profile) will score well on tests measuring comprehension and low on tests measuring decoding skills. Both skills are necessary for competent reading. If subtest scores are averaged for a single composite result, data showing a specific and profound weakness are eliminated. With score inflation, a dyslexic child’s isolated weakness is hidden, preventing meaningful understanding of the weakness.
Experience Shared from the Community:
The lead psychologist in our district glossed over several scores showing a profound weakness (results below the 10%), framing the relevant data as a “relative weakness when considering the child’s full profile.” However, this “relative weakness” represents exactly what requires focus, remediation, and specialized instruction. The low score anomalies are the disability, despite other high scores within the child’s profile.
4. Failure to Consider All Relevant Data
Under IDEA, schools must consider all data points, even those provided by independent evaluators. School-based psychologists and outside experts can produce conflicting results. Schools often favor internal data, which can create an incomplete picture of a child’s needs.
Experience Shared from the Community:
The lead psychologist in our district glossed over several scores showing a profound weakness (results below the 10%), framing the relevant data as a “relative weakness when considering the child’s full profile.” However, this “relative weakness” represents exactly what requires focus, remediation, and specialized instruction. The low score anomalies are the disability, despite other high scores within the child’s profile.
5. False Data
Even with the best intentions, sometimes there is a mistake in the data. Outlier data points are worth exploring. Parents should validate suspicious data by reviewing administration logs, qualifications of the test administrator, and applicable grade-level standards.
Experience Shared from the Community:
We asked for some information about data points used to withdraw SLD eligibility. The school shared that the “material was lost, but the score still stands” even though they are unsure about how the score was achieved. Eventually, the school re-administered the test and delivered a result that matched the reality of our child’s ability.
What You Can Do
It’s critical that complete and accurate data are used when making decisions about IEP eligibility. Here are five ways to examine the data as you and the team work to truly evaluate and understand your child’s unique needs.
- Review the assessment selection and request supplemental tests if necessary.
- Understand how universal accommodations like audio and extra time could impact a score.
- For composite scores, request a review of subtests in areas impacted by the disability.
- Ensure expert external data is reviewed critically—it’s the law.
- Trust your gut if a score seems off and ask for more information.

Join our email list
Subscribe to receive
The Latest from DyslexiaHelp
every other month.